top of page
bg white.png

What Futures Are We Unwilling to Imagine?

10 minutes ago
14 min read

Dreams and Disruptions, Odd Futures, and the Limits of Our Imagination


We spend a great deal of time imagining how the world might change. Yet I wonder how often we imagine a world that is fundamentally different from the one we already know.


In foresight, we examine emerging issues, identify drivers of change, and construct alternative scenarios. We imagine smarter cities, more advanced technologies, sustainable economies, and more efficient governments. But look closely at many of these futures and something becomes apparent: the institutions, assumptions, and relationships that define the present remain largely intact.


We imagine change without necessarily imagining transformation.


This was the question I wanted to explore during the Scenario Development Symposia: Odd Futures, held on October 13, 2026, as part of my Applied Strategic Foresight course at the Asian Institute of Management (AIM).


I invited six friends and colleagues who had used Dreams and Disruptions in different settings across Canada, Singapore, China, Australia, Switzerland, and the Philippines. I developed the game to explore an idea that had been with me for years: What happens when people are confronted with forces of change they did not choose, and with possibilities they might ordinarily dismiss as ridiculous?

The question for the panel was: How can we support people in envisioning futures that truly diverge from today?


I wanted to know what surprised people, what assumptions became visible, and what happened when participants began questioning the worlds they had imagined.


The stories the panelists shared, and the questions the students asked, surfaced several revealing contradictions.



We Can Imagine a Different Future Without Imagining a Different Distribution of Power

Stephanie Estra, an interdisciplinary futures practitioner based in Canada, shared her experience from a June 2025 session organized by the Canadian Foresight Network.


Her group drew three forces of change: vertical farming, atheism, and a social credit system. From these, they imagined a preferred future in 2050: a post-capitalist society organized around sustainability, shared resources, communal living, and collective well-being.


They then drew a disruption resembling a benevolent dictator, which appeared only to reinforce their imagined leader’s compassion and commitment to the collective good.


The scenario seemed coherent until Stephanie began questioning it after the game.


How could a supposedly equitable society remain dependent on centralized authority? Had they imagined a different political system, or merely a kinder version of the one they already knew?


Her assessment was candid: “We failed in making sure that the power relationships were different than what we live in today.” She subsequently explored these contradictions in an article.


We can imagine a different society without changing the relationships of power that govern it.


Consider development. We speak of inclusive growth, sustainable cities, and regenerative economies. But who controls resources? Who makes decisions? Who benefits from these arrangements?


In the Philippines, for example, we can easily imagine political dynasties continuing to dominate governance. That future is plausible because it is familiar.

But what would a future beyond political dynasties look like?


An anti-dynasty law may be necessary, but laws alone cannot transform deeply established political cultures. What institutions, relationships, and forms of public participation would have to emerge to make such a future possible?


We may find it easier to imagine better leaders than to imagine fundamentally different systems of leadership. And perhaps that is part of the problem.


Discovering That We Do Not Want Our Own Preferred Future


Carol Lim, founder of The Human Futures Practice in Singapore, shared an experience that I found equally revealing.


She facilitated Dreams and Disruptions with a group of participants who had little or no background in foresight. They imagined a preferred future in 2036 using forces such as sentient artificial intelligence, synthetic biology, vertical farming, polyarchy, and worker movements. Their disruption was Jurassic Resurgence.


Artificial intelligence quickly dominated the discussion.


Participants drew heavily on familiar films, particularly The Matrix, RoboCop, and Transformers. They imagined intelligent machines and increasingly sophisticated technologies.


Carol noticed how their stories reflected familiar cultural assumptions. Participants were concerned with controlling AI but struggled to imagine alternative political arrangements or the role worker movements might play.

Then, toward the end, came a simple question: “Does anyone here really want to live in this preferred future?”


They did not.


 Dreams and Disruptions at the Acorn Training hosted Tavern by the Dock, Singapore by Carol Lim.
 Dreams and Disruptions at the Acorn Training hosted Tavern by the Dock, Singapore by Carol Lim.

For all its technological sophistication, their imagined society did not reflect the kind of life they wanted. They began asking what it would mean to be human in such a world. What would relationships look like? What would give life meaning? What should remain unchanged?


I find this particularly striking.


We are becoming very good at imagining the future of technology. But are we equally capable of imagining the future of being human?


We imagine smarter cities without necessarily imagining stronger communities. We envision technological abundance without asking whether it will improve people’s lives.


During our AIM discussion, a student raised a related point about food security. Vertical farming and alternative food technologies could address important challenges, but they could also deepen inequalities if access remained concentrated among those who could afford them.


This is an important question in development: Innovation for whom? Who benefits? Who might be excluded?


A technological breakthrough does not automatically produce social progress. And a preferred future is not necessarily desirable simply because we call it preferred.


What If We Are Too Accustomed to Imagining Disaster?


Louis Zheng, co-founder of Futurist Circle and founding member of Future Matters in China, shared how Dreams and Disruptions had been adapted into Mandarin and used in education, community engagement, and climate futures initiatives.


After encountering the game at the Dubai Future Forum in 2023, he helped launch its Mandarin edition in December 2024.


He has since used it in climate futures activities, including sessions connected with Bangkok Climate Action Week.


Louis observed that climate conversations are often dominated by catastrophe: rising temperatures, extreme weather, ecological collapse, and the consequences of inaction.


These concerns are real. But he noticed that some participants had become so accustomed to imagining disaster that other possibilities rarely entered the conversation. Through the game, participants began exploring futures beyond familiar narratives of climate crisis. Some moved from climate anxiety toward a greater sense of possibility and hope.


Louis traced part of the difficulty to education systems that condition students to search for the correct answer. The game, he suggested, invites a different question: “What if there’s not only one answer?”


I think this matters.


Foresight is not about convincing people that everything will be fine. Nor is it about avoiding difficult realities. It is about recognizing that the future is not singular. When catastrophe becomes the only imaginable future, we risk losing sight of our capacity to intervene.


The same tendency appears in development. We repeatedly study poverty, corruption, unemployment, and environmental degradation. Yet our preferred futures often consist of incremental reductions in these problems.


Less poverty. Less corruption. Less pollution.


These are important aspirations. But why do we find it so difficult to imagine fundamentally different arrangements that might address the conditions sustaining them?


During our discussion of emerging issues, one student offered a particularly interesting observation: emerging issues are not always about things appearing. They can also involve things disappearing.


We scan for new technologies, industries, and behaviors. But what about disappearing languages, weakening communities, declining ecological relationships, or the loss of collective memory?


Sometimes the most consequential change is not what emerges, but what we no longer notice is missing.



Louis Zheng facilitating the Dreams and Disruptions in one of Futurist Circle events in Shanghai, China.
Louis Zheng facilitating the Dreams and Disruptions in one of Futurist Circle events in Shanghai, China.

Perhaps We Are Solving the Wrong Problem

Ronna Puntawe, a doctoral researcher at the University of Sydney Business School and board member of Social Enterprise Australia, shared an experience from a two-day Flourishing Futures workshop involving 20 doctoral researchers.


One scenario imagined preschool children using digital twins capable of learning on their behalf.


What would education mean if a digital representation could acquire knowledge for a child? Would schools continue to operate as they do today? What would teachers do? What would distinguish learning from information processing?

The scenario was strange, but it raised questions about assumptions we rarely challenge.


Earlier in our AIM class, we had been discussing the classroom shortage in the Philippines. The conventional response is to build more classrooms. We debate construction targets, budgets, procurement, and infrastructure requirements.


But I asked my students: What if we stopped thinking about classrooms and started thinking about learning?


One group explored the deliberately ridiculous idea of building no conventional classrooms for the next 30 years. Another recalled Efren Peñaflorida’s pushcart classrooms, which brought learning to children in the streets.


The point was not to abandon school infrastructure; we need safe and adequate learning spaces. The point was to question why our imagination of education remains confined to familiar institutional arrangements.


A student working in housing policy made a similar observation, realizing that even when imagining the future, their thinking remained bounded by existing housing policies.


This is something professionals should reflect on. Expertise helps us understand how systems work, but it can also make us increasingly attached to those systems. We become very good at improving existing arrangements while struggling to imagine alternatives.


Sometimes our inability to solve a problem comes from our unwillingness to question how we have defined it.


A Dreams Disruptions Workshop at the University of Sydney's Business School organized by Ronna Puntawe.
A Dreams Disruptions Workshop at the University of Sydney's Business School organized by Ronna Puntawe.

Whose Future Are We Imagining?


Elaine France, founder of Flourishing Futures Collective and Futuring with Mountains, shared her experiences using Dreams and Disruptions with culturally diverse young people through Futures Wonder Labs and other learning activities. Her work brings together futures literacy, intercultural dialogue, identity, regeneration, and our relationship with nature.


Elaine observed how the game created opportunities for participants to engage across cultural differences. Their languages, experiences, identities, and relationships with nature became resources for imagining futures. In her words, the game creates “that breathing space to go beyond the edge of reason and have this permission to do it.”


She also raised an important concern about the dominance of Western assumptions in development. We often invite culturally diverse communities into futures conversations while continuing to use frameworks that privilege particular understandings of progress, prosperity, and modernization.


We listen to different voices without necessarily allowing those voices to change the terms of the conversation. Elaine urged us to ask not only who is present, but “who’s not in the room or who is in the room and doesn’t feel heard or doesn’t feel able to speak.” Inclusion is not simply a matter of inviting people; it requires that they can meaningfully shape the conversation.


I have encountered this contradiction in my own work. We speak about Indigenous knowledge, local wisdom, and community participation. Yet these perspectives are frequently expected to fit within institutional frameworks that were not developed from their experiences.


Elaine also observed that participants often found it difficult to imagine futures in which nature was central rather than treated primarily as a resource.


This resonates with my research on river futures in Philippine cities. We tend to understand rivers through infrastructure, flood control, environmental management, and economic activity. But rivers are also part of our cultures, histories, identities, and relationships. What futures become imaginable when we begin with these relationships rather than with infrastructure alone?


What appears strange in one community may be entirely sensible in another.


Perhaps a future seems impossible not because it cannot exist, but because our assumptions prevent us from recognizing it.


Elaine's France Future Games 4 Democracy event that uses the Dreams and Disruptions to facilitate imagination and conversations about alternative futures of democracy.
Elaine's France Future Games 4 Democracy event that uses the Dreams and Disruptions to facilitate imagination and conversations about alternative futures of democracy.

When Students Discover Their Capacity to Shape the Future

Jezreel Caunca, director of Northwestern University’s Philippine Center for Foresight Education and Innovation Research, shared how Dreams and Disruptions has been integrated into futures thinking education and youth engagement activities.


By his account, approximately 3,000 to 4,000 students and young people have played the game across different parts of the Philippines.


What surprised him was the diversity of scenarios. Despite using the same game, students kept producing different imagined worlds. Sometimes they asked to change their cards because the combinations were unfamiliar or difficult.


But that is precisely the challenge. As Jezreel put it, “They are being forced to argue for a future that they hadn’t picked.” We do not get to choose every disruption that confronts us. Yet we must decide how to respond. Ronna offered a complementary reflection: “Regardless of the randomness of the future, we still have a choice with the imagination that we have.”


Students from nursing, criminology, architecture, engineering, and other disciplines were encouraged to imagine themselves working in radically different societies. They began questioning not only what their professions might become, but also how they might contribute to shaping those futures.


In one evaluation involving 119 students, 90 percent supported game-based learning, while 75.6 percent reported changes in their beliefs or assumptions about the future. Some translated their scenarios into prototypes and dioramas. One architecture class even transformed its classroom into an imagined future environment.


These are encouraging observations, although further research would be needed to understand their longer-term effects.


What interests me is the possibility that young people can begin seeing themselves not merely as future workers or professionals, but as participants in creating society. We often tell young people that they are the future. But are we giving them enough opportunities to imagine futures different from the ones we have inherited?


One of the many Dreams and Disruptions Game hosted by the PhilForesight Institute at Northwestern University
One of the many Dreams and Disruptions Game hosted by the PhilForesight Institute at Northwestern University

Can We Bring This Kind of Imagination into Development Planning?

One of the most practical questions during the AIM conversation came from a student working in local government: What if municipalities, cities, and barangays explored their alternative futures before preparing comprehensive development plans?


Instead of immediately asking what infrastructure should be built, what if they first imagined what their communities might become in 20, 30, or 50 years? What if local governments were confronted with disruptions such as declining national tax allocations or climate-related changes in livelihoods? Would their plans look different?


I find this worth exploring because development planning is often driven by institutional requirements, funding arrangements, existing mandates, and familiar projects. We ask what can be implemented within the current system.


But how often do we ask whether the current system is capable of producing the future we desire?


Another student raised a methodological question: How do we balance imagining unlikely futures with ensuring that scenarios remain relevant to real development challenges?


It is a fair question. Odd futures should not replace evidence, policy analysis, or practical decision-making. But they can help us examine the assumptions behind those processes.


Stephanie suggested that the game develops our capacity to think differently: “Our brain is a muscle and if we don’t give ourselves the opportunity to be imaginative, be creative and think outside the box, we’re not going to be able to do it as a society.” Luis offered a similar image, comparing repeated futures exercises to going to the gym: imagination becomes something we practice, rather than an occasional activity.


I like that comparison. Perhaps foresight should not be confined to annual strategic planning workshops or occasional scenario exercises. Organizations and communities could create regular opportunities to challenge assumptions, explore uncomfortable possibilities, and reconsider familiar development questions.


Not every conversation has to produce a policy or strategy. Sometimes it needs to produce a better question.


What the Six Cases Offered


Listening to the practitioners, I began to see a common thread. The most interesting discoveries were not always the scenarios participants created, but what they began questioning afterward.


Practitioner and Organization

What Became Visible

Insight

Stephanie Estra

Canada

Canadian Foresight Network; global engineering and consulting firm

A post-capitalist preferred future retained centralized power.

Different futures can reproduce existing political relationships.

Carol Lim

Singapore

The Human Futures Practice

Participants created a technologically advanced future they did not want to inhabit.

Preferred futures are not necessarily desirable.

Luis Seng

China

Futurist Circle; Future Matters

Climate scenarios encouraged some participants to move beyond catastrophe narratives.

Imagination can open possibilities for agency and action.

Ronna

Australia

University of Sydney Business School; Social Enterprise Australia

Digital twins challenged assumptions about schooling and learning.

Transformative thinking begins by questioning how problems are defined.

Elaine France

Switzerland

Flourishing Futures Collective; Futuring with Mountains

Cultural identities and relationships with nature shaped what participants could imagine.

Our imagination is culturally situated, never entirely neutral.

Jezreel Caunca

Philippines

PhilForesight, Northwestern University

Students imagined unfamiliar futures and reconsidered their professional roles.

Futures education can help young people recognize their agency.

 

These accounts do not establish that the game produces the same outcomes everywhere. The participants, contexts, and approaches were different. But the cases raise a compelling possibility.


The value of an unfamiliar future may lie in what it reveals about the familiar present.


Stephanie’s scenario exposed assumptions about power. Carol’s revealed the limits of technology-centered imagination. Other cases raised questions about climate, education, cultural identity, and human agency. The students at AIM extended these questions into governance, development planning, infrastructure, and inequality.


What emerged was not simply a collection of unusual scenarios. It was an opportunity to examine how our assumptions shape what we consider possible.


The Real Work Begins When We Question Ourselves


When I prepared the symposium guide, I organized the conversation around three areas: experience, discovery, and implications. What happened? What became visible? What might change in practice?


After listening to the different accounts, I became more interested in the questions people asked after imagining their scenarios. Why did we imagine that future? What did we leave unquestioned? Whose perspectives were missing? What assumptions did we carry from the present?


This is where reflexivity matters. We can become highly proficient in foresight methods without questioning ourselves. We can develop elaborate scenarios while retaining familiar assumptions about leadership, governance, progress, and development. Even our preferred futures can contain contradictions that we fail to recognize.


I increasingly see Dreams and Disruptions as an opportunity for what I would call anticipatory reflexivity: encountering unfamiliar futures as a way of critically examining the assumptions that guide our decisions today.


The game does not guarantee such reflection. Facilitation, dialogue, and the willingness to confront uncomfortable questions all matter. But the experiences shared during the symposium suggest that this is worth investigating further.


Perhaps the most important part of a futures game happens after the game.


Applied Strategic Foresight Course at the Masters in Development Mangement Class 2027, Asian Institute of Management
Applied Strategic Foresight Course at the Masters in Development Mangement Class 2027, Asian Institute of Management

What Future Are We Unwilling to Imagine?


So, what future are we currently unable, or unwilling, to imagine? I think there is an important difference between the two.


Some futures are difficult to imagine because we lack the knowledge, experiences, or perspectives needed to recognize them. Others are difficult because imagining them would require us to question our interests, identities, privileges, or positions of power.


A business leader may find it difficult to imagine an economy organized around fundamentally different ideas of ownership. A public official may struggle to imagine governance arrangements that redistribute authority away from established institutions. An educator may find it difficult to imagine learning beyond schools and classrooms. Even futurists may struggle to imagine futures that challenge the concepts and methods on which their expertise depends.


I developed Dreams and Disruptions partly to explore what happens when randomness confronts us with futures we would not ordinarily choose. But these experiences have led me to a more difficult question.


What happens when we encounter a future that challenges not only our expectations, but also our place in the world? We tend to associate foresight with anticipating change. Yet anticipating change does not necessarily mean being willing to change.


We can imagine extraordinary technologies, different economies, and alternative political systems while remaining attached to the arrangements that sustain the present. This is why I think the distinction between what is plausible and what is possible deserves greater attention.


Plausibility often reflects what we know and what existing systems allow us to consider credible. But the future is not limited to the continuation of what is already familiar.


That does not mean abandoning evidence or practical judgment. It means refusing to treat current institutions and assumptions as the permanent boundaries of imagination. The challenge for foresight is not simply to generate more scenarios. It is to examine why certain futures are easy to imagine, why others seem ridiculous, and why some possibilities make us uncomfortable.


We need leaders who can do more than anticipate disruptions. Ronna, returning to an idea I had raised earlier in the session, put it simply: “Imagination is your currency as a leader.” 


We need people willing to question the assumptions and institutions that may themselves require disruption. And this brings me back to the question that started our conversation:


What if the greatest obstacle to creating fundamentally different futures is not uncertainty about what lies ahead, but our attachment to the world we already know?


Perhaps the futures we find most difficult to imagine are precisely those that demand the most change from us. And perhaps that is where the real work of foresight begins.


Luis closed the symposium by reading a reflection written by a participant in one of his game sessions. I can think of no better way to end:


“In the space of game narratives, I can set aside the pressing issues of everyday life. Step out, gaze at a longer, more widening river of time.


In this open, imaginative space, the future is no longer just a single continuation, but full of forks, choices and possibilities for change.


It’s not just about grand narratives like society and environment, but about the lives of specific people and characters.


The future comes from every decision and imagination we have today. It is the sum of choices and the result of the interplay between imagination and action.

For me, this is not just a game experience, but more like a practice of thinking and imagination and [an] attempt to establish a deep connection with our future.”

— Participant reflection, shared by Louis Zheng


The future, in this sense, is neither a single continuation of the present nor something detached from our everyday lives. It emerges through the interplay of imagination, decision, and action.


Which brings me back, one last time, to the question in the title: What future are we currently unable, or unwilling, to imagine?

    *

Shermon Cruz is the UNESCO Chair on Anticipatory Governance and Regenerative Cities at Northwestern University, Philippines, and the creator of Dreams and Disruptions and Adjunct Faculty at the Asian Institute of Management . This essay draws on the Scenario Development Symposia: Odd Futures, held on October 13, 2026, during his Applied Strategic Foresight course at the Asian Institute of Management.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page